Search for:

Motorcycle insurance can be paid either monthly or yearly, depending on your preference and the options the insurance company provides.

Monthly premiums offer more flexibility in budgeting, while annual payments often come with potential discounts.

Didn't You Try Our Quote Comparison Tool Yet? Save BIG by Doing it!

It’s essential to compare and choose the payment frequency that suits your financial situation and needs.

Is It Cheaper to Pay Motorcycle Insurance Yearly?

For most riders, purchasing an annual insurance policy that you pay in full will cost less each year. Even if a discount is not included with the lump-sum payment, you can avoid installment fees totaling $3 or more with some providers.

Many insurers provide a 10% or greater discount for choosing to pay your motorcycle insurance in full each year.

motorcycle insurance quote saving banner

While it requires a larger upfront payment, it can result in a lower overall premium than monthly payments. It helps to Always inquire about potential savings and choose the payment frequency that aligns with your budget and preferences.

What Motorcycle Insurance Companies Offer the Biggest Discounts?

When searching for motorcycle insurance quotes for a Ninja 400, I first went to Allstate, Progressive, and GEICO. These three agencies tend to get the most traffic, so I wanted to see what they could offer me for my bike.

GEICO didn’t offer me a pay-in-full discount. They pointed out that I could pay fewer installment fees across 12 months. The savings was less than $50 to go in that direction with a policy that was just under $150 monthly for my premiums.

I went to Allstate next to discuss the Ninja 400. They asked for $135 per month, then offered to take off 10% if I paid everything in full. Additional discounts were available if I wanted to bundle home or auto with the motorcycle.

Progressive’s rates were the lowest, offering $118 for full coverage. They also provided a 10% discount and eliminated monthly admin fees if I were to pay everything in full when starting the new policy.

Enter ZIP to Check How Much YOU Can Save

In total, the biggest savings was about $130. The lowest overall total came from Progressive. GEICO gave me the most expensive rate and didn’t offer a discount if I immediately paid off the entire balance.

Here’s the comparison of motorcycle insurance quotes for a Ninja 400 from Allstate, GEICO, and Progressive:

ProviderMonthly PremiumPay-in-Full Discount

When Does It Make Sense to Pay My Motorcycle Insurance in Full?

Paying motorcycle insurance in full makes sense when you have the financial means to do so without straining your budget.

It can lead to cost savings through potential discounts insurance companies offer for annual payments. If you’re confident in your ability to make a lump-sum payment and want to minimize administrative fees, paying in full upfront can be a practical and cost-effective choice.

It doesn’t make sense to take on debt to make this payment. Credit card fees and higher interest rates would cause you to lose most, if not all, of the pay-in-full savings.

If you have trouble meeting your motorcycle insurance premiums, consider raising your deductible if you’re required to have full coverage.

Do you own your motorcycle outright? If so, a liability-only policy could be the best option for keeping your costs low.

Are Motorcycle Insurance Features the Same in Monthly vs. Yearly Plans?

The features of motorcycle insurance generally remain consistent whether you choose a monthly or yearly payment plan.

Both choices provide similar coverage options, including liability, collision, and comprehensive protection.

The primary difference between these options is payment frequency and potential cost savings opportunities. It’s essential to review the details of each plan and consider your budget and preferences when deciding between the different payment options.

GEICO offers different splits, including three- and nine-month payment choices. Other providers may offer similar options for your motorcycle insurance. The best to choose works with your current and future budget.

What If Neither Option Makes Sense for Me?

When your motorcycle ownership or riding plans involve a couple of days, weeks, or months, it might be more cost-effective to use a temporary insurance policy.

Although the per-day cost of temporary motorcycle insurance is higher than other choices, it can be the least expensive option for short-term needs.

It offers flexibility and cost-effectiveness for limited usage. However, suppose you ride your motorcycle frequently throughout the year. A traditional annual insurance policy might provide better overall coverage and value in that case.

That’s why it is essential to carefully evaluate your needs and usage habits to ensure you choose the best option.

Use This Tool for Free and Save on Quotes!


Mike Navarette has more than a decade of experience in the auto insurance industry, but that's not his true passion. He loves getting on a motorcycle to explore roads he's never traveled. You'll find Mike in the garage working on something when he isn't helping clients or leaning into curves. It's sometimes a side hustle, more often a favor, but it keeps his hands busy doing something productive. Since the first time his father strapped on his helmet and took him for a ride, Mike has loved bikes. That passion, along with a desire to help others through a deep understanding of insurance policies, led to the creation of Motorcycle Ride Coverage.

Write A Comment